Jessica Yaniv Files Complaint After Being Denied Gynecological Care Due to Transgender Status
Jessica Yaniv, a transgender woman from Canada, has filed a formal complaint after being denied care by a gynecologist who allegedly refused treatment based on her gender identity. The case has reignited discussions about access to healthcare for transgender patients, medical ethics, and the responsibilities of healthcare professionals.
Yaniv shared her experience on social media, describing the response from the gynecologist’s office as simply, “We don’t serve transgender patients.” She expressed feeling “shocked, confused, and hurt” by the rejection, and questioned the legality of such a refusal. She tagged the College of Physicians and Surgeons of British Columbia in her post, seeking clarification on whether this practice violates medical regulations.
In response, the College stated that while they do not give legal opinions on individual cases discussed over the phone, they encourage patients to consult official practice standards and file complaints if necessary.
This incident is not Yaniv’s first legal action regarding discrimination. In 2019, she filed complaints against several estheticians who refused to perform waxing services on her male genitalia. The British Columbia Human Rights Tribunal ultimately dismissed those complaints, stating that her primary motivation appeared to be personal gain rather than addressing systemic discrimination.
The Ongoing Debate Around Transgender Healthcare
The gynecologist involved in the current case has not made a public statement. However, similar cases have highlighted the complex intersection between a doctor’s scope of practice and the need for inclusive care.
Experts note that transgender women who have undergone gender-affirming surgery may require care that differs from that provided to cisgender women. For example, neo-vaginas require specific medical knowledge, and transgender women typically do not need routine cervical or uterine exams because they do not have those organs.
Some doctors argue that they are not trained to provide such specialized care and may refer patients elsewhere. However, this has raised concerns about whether these referrals are appropriate or simply an excuse to deny treatment.
Access Denied: Health Consequences of Discrimination
When transgender individuals are denied medical care, the impact goes beyond emotional harm—it can lead to serious health risks. In one notable case, a transgender man was denied gynecological care multiple times and was eventually diagnosed with ovarian cancer after a year-long delay.
Research supports these concerns: nearly 25% of transgender people avoid seeking medical care due to fear of mistreatment, and almost half of those who do seek care report negative experiences with providers.
A Call for Clearer Standards and Training
Medical experts agree that better education and clearer guidelines are key. One transgender health advocate emphasized, “It’s not acceptable to say, ‘I don’t know about trans people, so I won’t treat them.’ But at the same time, we need to acknowledge that some treatments require specific knowledge.”
As more people seek gender-affirming care, healthcare systems face increasing pressure to provide respectful, competent, and inclusive services. Yaniv’s case remains under review, but it underscores the urgent need to balance patient rights with provider responsibilities—and to ensure that no one is left without care simply because of who they are.
Would you like this adapted into a shorter summary or formatted as a news article?